Pillow Talking’s Review of TITANIC THE MUSICAL

Someday Productions LLC and Pillow Talking are pleased to present the following review of TITANIC THE MUSICAL by The Opera House Players at the Broad Brook Opera House


Through May 21st

For information and tickets

She Said:

For over a century, interest and fascination in the events surrounding the infamous sinking of the Titanic have been inexhaustible. Who wouldn’t be curious about the massive, luxury ocean liner which landed at the bottom of the Atlantic after colliding with an iceberg? That which led to the untimely deaths of over 1,500 innocent people. But beyond that, countless themes abound both about what led up to and what happened during the disaster. Did it demonstrate for us the limitations of technology or the unparalleled power of nature? Did it illuminate man’s very human frailties including his inadequacies, overconfidence, and oversight? Did it bring to light the hollow notions of social class and privilege, entitlement and greed, juxtaposed against the noble virtues of courage, compromise, altruism, and the preciousness of all life – as well as countless other aspects (both negative and positive) of human nature? The answer is yes. Yes to all of this and more.

Titanic PublicityNow on to matters of this century – namely, The Opera House Players’ grand production of Titanic: The Musical, directed by theatre vet Sharon FitzHenry, with book by Peter Stone and music & lyrics by Maury Yeston. Titanic is the five-time Tony Award winning musical which debuted on Broadway in 1997 to great acclaim. The word “titanic” is derived from Greek mythology and means, not surprisingly, gigantic. I therefore could use many predictably unoriginal and altogether overused adjectives here; words such as colossal, mammoth, or immense to describe the theatrical undertaking, but I won’t (or did I already do so? wink, wink!). Instead I will say that work of The Players at Broad Brook Opera House, unlike that of those on the actual maiden voyage of the White Star Line’s RMS Titanic, resulted in a great success. With a large cast featuring 21+ actors playing over 50 roles, the production was quite an impressive feat.

Ordinarily in a theatre review, I’ll illustrate only select elements of the initial plot structure to entice and titillate readers – and as a firm disbeliever in spoilers, I’ll only take it so far. But as in the classic five-act dramatic pattern, the events of the sinking of the Titanic need little introduction and therefore there’s nothing I really can disclose that isn’t already known. However, the way in which it all has been woven into this compelling and emotional musical journey, it will draw you in and have you holding your breath; and all the while you’ll be wishing the story will have an entirely different ending.

Few don’t know the exposition: we first are told of the incredible feat of engineering of the luxury liner, with her opulence and richness in excess; and about it we hear “How Did They Build Titanic?” and “There She Is” sung by many in the company. It also speaks to the dreams of its passengers: her Third Class or steerage passengers (those emigrating to America for a better life) and Second Class (those who wish to emulate the wealthy) sing “I Must Get on that Ship.” About the First Class passengers (the wealthy), a starry-eyed patron of Second Class, Alice, sings of the “First Class Roster,” which included none other than Isador and Ida Straus of Macy’s department store, and mining tycoon Benjamin Guggenheim. In the rising action, the “unsinkable” Titanic is pushed past her limits of speed and warnings of an iceberg ahead are ignored – mainly because an overzealous chairman and owner of the White Star Line, J. Bruce Ismay, was more concerned about her reputation and getting to New York on time.

We also well know the climax. As the company sings “Finale Act One,” the Titanic tragically strikes the looming ‘berg. In the ensuing falling action, frantic passengers (mainly First and Second Class) scurry to the upper decks hoping to board one the sadly insufficient supply of lifeboats “To the Lifeboats.” Ultimately, in the denouement, innumerable lives are lost and the Titanic’s survivors are devastated.

Titanic Publicity-4If Titanic itself was a feat to produce, then listing the strengths of every actor would be a nearly impossible task. I will name each of them but will simply state for brevity, that they as a cohesive company did an incredible job: Jen Augeri as Caroline Neville/Mme. Aubert/Stewardess; Alexander Bilodeau as Bellboy/Jack Thayer/3rd Class Passenger; Carl Cannella as William Murdoch/Bass Player; Gene Choquette as Joseph Bell/Wallace Hartley/George Widener/Frank Carlson; Randy Davidson as Harold Bride/DaMico/2nd Class Passenger/3rd Class Passenger; Paul DiProto as Joseph Boxhall/Edgar Beane/3rd Class Passenger; Joe Finckel as Charles Clarke; Glenn Gordon as Robert Hitchens/Isidor Strauss/3rd Class Passenger; Zach Gray as Charles LIghtolier/2nd Class Passenger/3rd Class Passenger; Katie Harden as Marion Thayer/Kate Mullins/Stewardess; Stephen Jewell as Thomas Andrews; Tara Kennedy as Alice Beane/3rd Class Passenger; Jennifer MacPherson as Charlotte Drake Cardoza/Kate McGowan/DaMico; Michael Graham Morales as Frederick Barrett/John B. Thayer/3rd Class Passenger; Jay Newirth as Ida Straus/3rd Class Passenger; Shaun O’Keefe as Stoker/Benjamin Guggenheim/Jim Farrell; Tim Reilly as J. Bruce Ismay; Dennis J. Scott as Captain E. J. Smith; Andrew D. Secker as Frederick Fleet/Stoker/John Jacob Astor/3rd Class Passenger; Emily Smith as Stewardess/Madeline Astor/Kate Murphey; and Danny Viets as Herbert J. Pitman/Henry Etches. (Now my fingers are sore!!)

I will note, however that some stand out characters and performances were delivered in no particular order by Reilly as the loathsome J. Bruce Ismay; Scott as the commanding E. J. Smith, Captain; Cannella as the weary and weak William Murdoch; Morales as the astute and concerned Frederick Barrett; Viets as the dedicated and hard-working Henry Etches; Kennedy as the hysterically funny First Class wannabe, Alice Beane; and MacPherson as the spirited Kate McGowan. Moving portrayals by the loving but doomed Strauses also were given by Gordon and Newirth

Titanic Publicity-2So as not to detract from the cast or the action, the set was simple with but a few moveable set pieces, thanks to the economical design of FitzHenry (who also did lighting design), Francisco Aguas (also technical designer, construction manager, and crew), and Audrey Corman as scenic artist. A big hand to the rest of the construction crew, lighting operators and crew as well. Shout outs also must go to Bill Martin as musical director (also on keyboards) for the terrific orchestral accompaniment with Ann-Marie Messbauer on violin, Mallory Kokus on reeds, and Kevin Barker on percussion. Kudos to Aileen Marino Terzi as choreographer of “Latest Rag”; to Moonyean Field as producer and costumer with her costume crew and wig consultant, Erica Romeo; to Daniel Pear as stage manager; and to the props crew. It’s nearly impossible to name all of the production personnel, but suffice it to say, it takes a village and they all should receive a well-deserved nod. (We did experience some considerable mic issues on opening night – but with a cast this large, it was not surprising.)

Should the tale of Titanic: The Musical have been all tragedy, it likely would be impossibly hard to sit through. Instead, as in life, there are comical, tender, and happy moments. There also are many threads of hope and stories of survival. Life did go on for many and lessons ultimately were learned. And it is through FitzHenry’s skilled direction that the ginormous cast moves about the modest stage with ease and authenticity, bringing each individual character to life. Thank you to the Opera House Players for tackling this behemoth and for doing so with the style and elegance this significant piece of history deserves.


He Said:

“There is no danger that Titanic will sink. The boat is unsinkable and nothing but inconvenience will be suffered by the passengers” – Phillip Franklin, White Star Line Vice-President

I think it is only fair to disclose right up front that I am a Titanic buff. I became one after seeing the 1958 film A Night to Remember on television in the 60s. As a kid, I went overboard (pun intended) and gobbled up any information related to the Titanic. So no matter how good or bad Broad Brook’s production of the musical version of Titanic, I was going to be biased.

I will say as objectively as I can, and after 30 years in the theater and film business, Broad Brook’s production of Titanic: The Musical is – in a word – terrific.

Titanic: The Musical with story and book by Peter Stone and music and lyrics by Maury Yeston, opened on Broadway in 1997 and was termed “unsinkable.” It was nominated for five Tony awards and won in all five categories including Best Musical. According to Broad Brook’s Director’s Notes, “the theatrical immensity of the set rivalled the original vessel. Three decks tall, pieces which swiveled and tilted, hydraulics blazing. It was a spectacle to behold.” One of my biggest regrets in my culture-vulturism was that I never saw the Broadway show despite being a lunatic groupie. Other than the fact that it was the year my son, Wyatt, was born, I was producing, directing, and writing three Titanic projects (see my shameless plug below).*

Titanic Publicity-6The obvious “immensity” of the show made it prohibitive for national touring, regional, and community productions from both a financial and technical standpoint. Fortunately, Don Stephenson, one of the original Broadway cast members developed a “Chamber” or “Ensemble” version that was more amenable to smaller theatre houses. The Ensemble version reduced the cast, set, and music elements, but did not reduce the overall drama and/or intensity of the disaster. The Ensemble version reduced the cast to twenty actors who nevertheless had to double and play fifty-plus parts, including characters from all three classes: first, second and steerage or third.

I was counting down the days to Broad Brook’s opening, especially since the anniversary of the Titanic, April 15, 1912, has just passed. But I asked myself, even with the reduced cast and band members, how could Broad Brook pull it off knowing the spatial limitations of the theatre?

I am pleased to say that Broad Brook successfully did what history could not: it kept the Titanic afloat. The Opera House did it with the same skills they invest in all of their production: ingenuity, hard work, great casting and direction, and a love and devotion to the craft of theatre.

Titanic Publicity-7The acting was top-notch, not a weak link in the talented Ensemble. The cast is far too large to dive into each actor’s strengths as I usually do. Suffice it to say, the entire cast worked together as one, each a team member and each in sync with their fellow actor.  I was not only amazed as the actors quickly morphed from one character to another, but also how quickly they changed costumes and, in some cases, hairpieces. I would be remiss if I did not mention that everything was not completely smooth sailing. There were some opening night microphone/audio glitches and some of the scene changes seemed a bit awkward (although they were moving the largest movable object on Earth). But, overall, the behemoth of a production worked exceedingly well – much better than the Titanic itself.

Titanic Publicity-5I must note, having worked on Titanic projects that the casting of one role is particularly key – and that is Captain E.J. Smith. In many ways, the Captain represents the ship itself – a man larger than life; one who seems impervious to human frailty. In James Cameron’s version, distinguished actor (who also worked on one my projects) Bernard Hill played him. In A Night to Remember it was famed, British character actor (who had an extensive seafaring background as well) Laurence Naismith. And in the 1996 television mini-series, Titanic, the late, great George C. Scott played him. The casting of Dennis J. Scott in the role of the Captain was an excellent decision. Mr. Scott had a commanding presence on stage that fit nicely within the tradition of his predecessors. While I’ve seen Danny Viets in other shows at Broad Brook, watching him play Henry Etches in this one reminded me of a young Roddy McDowell – especially when he played a yacht servant in the comedy Overboard. I feel compelled to bring this up since I mentioned this odd thing to Mr. Viets on the way out of the theatre without any further explanation and I wanted him to have an “aha” moment.

The success of Broad Brook’s Titanic was definitely buoyed by the able-bodied musical direction by Bill Martin and Artistic Direction by Sharon FitzHenry. They both did yeoman’s work in keeping this mammoth production on course! The Ensemble version works in a theatre like Broad Brook because as Ms. FitzHenry says, it “turns the focus back to the men and women of that fateful night.” I had chills when Isidor Straus (Glenn Gordon) and Ida Straus (Jayne Newirth), the owners of Macy’s who decided to die together on the Titanic, renewed their marriage vows.

The story of the Titanic certainly is a cautionary tale of the often disastrous consequences of humankind’s often extreme hubris, challenging both nature and the powers that be. Like Icarus flying too high to the sun, or the biblical Tower of Babel, we must be wary of reaching too high too fast, leaving caution to the winds. As Eva Hart, one of the survivors of the Titanic commented, “My mother had a premonition from the very word ‘GO.’ She knew there was something to be afraid of and the only thing that she felt strongly about was that to say a ship was unsinkable was flying in the face of God. Those were her words.”

The Titanic has a special place in history and in our collective consciousness, not because of the severity of the disaster (although it was great) but rather the magnanimity of humankind’s best qualities that were exhibited by people who knew they were about to die: courage, generosity, sacrifice, hope, and, most of all, love.

Even though Broad Brook’s Titanic will definitely not sink and there will be clear sailing for it for the rest of its run, I recommend catching this authentic human interest tale told by a seaworthy cast and crew. So run down to the gangplank and get a ticket before it leaves.

* Of my projects, the first was a restoration of the first full-length sound film done on the Titanic in 1929 called Disaster in the Atlantic. The other two, a cinematic and audiobook version, were based on the 1912 Senate Hearings into the disaster and featured an international cast of actors from former Titanic projects. David McCallum, from A Night to Remember, hosted all three. Even though John Cunningham and David Garrison from the original Broadway cast were in my productions, as I said, regrettably I never got to see it on Broadway.

By the way, all three of my works are available on my Wayne’s You Tube channel – sorry for the shameless plug.

 Read Pillow Talking’s Other Theatre Reviews



Stephanie & Wayne

About Stephanie & Wayne

Stephanie is a journalist, writer, editor, and has had several hundred articles published in various newspapers and magazines, many of which still are available online under “Stephanie Lyons Schultz”. She has a Masters degree in Counseling Psychology and was a practicing psychotherapist. She currently is a professor of psychology at WCSU and NVCC in Connecticut. Wayne is an Emmy-Award winning writer, producer, and director. He has produced many programs and documentaries that have appeared on television, and have been distributed to schools, libraries, and home video. Wayne also is a practicing attorney with a Masters degree in Law from NYU. In addition, he is a professor of communications at WCSU. Together, this recently wed couple write, produce, and direct as many of their stage, screen, and TV projects as they can with a full house -- their combined brood of seven! Some of their work has been featured this summer and fall off off Broadway; other work currently is under option. They hope to continue to promote more of their projects in the coming months! Feel free to write whatever comments you like! We want your feedback!