Pillow Talking’s Review of NEWSIES

Someday Productions LLC and Pillow Talking are pleased to present its review of NEWSIES at the Westchester Broadway Theatre (WBT)


Through May 26th

For Information or to Purchase Tickets


She Said:

Having reviewed hundreds of theatrical productions, from straight plays to musicals, from dramatic to comedic, and from Shakespeare to Disney to new works, there are few surprises that cross my path. It can also be a challenge to see productions for the second, third, or even fifth or sixth times and come up with something new to say about them. But then there’s a gem – a play or a musical that just stands out – one that from start to finish is a polished, masterful confection featuring a great story, multi-talented performers who can both tear up the boards and blow the roof off a theatre, dazzling sets, and staging and direction that truly knock your socks off. Westchester Broadway Theatre’s (WBT) Newsies, under the guiding hand of skilled director Mark Martino, is one such production. And while I usually wait until the last line of my review to say so, RUN, don’t walk to your computer or the box office to get your tickets before they’re gone!

With a lively book written by Harvey Fierstein (based on the Disney film written by Bob Tzudiker and Noni White), Newsies is about the real newsboys’ strike of 1899, when young orphaned and homeless pape-toters stood up to tycoons Joseph Pulitzer of The World and William Randolph Hearst of The Journal to demand fair wages and acceptable treatment. After the Spanish-American War ended, the unscrupulous publishers found themselves with little to fill their pages in order to continue lining their own over-filled pockets, so they instead elected to raise the price per paper, resulting in a drastic reduction to the poor newsboys’ profits. The pennies they’d been earning barely allowed them to eke by as it was, and they had no other options to survive. But, with strength and support in numbers, the boys (and at WBT, girls, too!) pushed back! They organized a union and staged a strike. “If we stand as one / Someday becomes somehow…” is the poignant line from the song “Seize the Day.”

x34091A7E577-6291-406F-AA5D872ADCDBE876.jpg.pagespeed.ic.GEkVxgpxviThe icing on the proverbial cake and that which makes Newsies even more incredible are the songs and choreography – it rises to the level of spectacular. With music by Alan Menken and lyrics by Jack Feldman, orchestrations by Danny Troob, incidental music and vocal arrangements by Michael Kosarin, and dance arrangements by Mark Hummel, WBT’s production also features choreography by Shea Sullivan and musical direction by Bob Bray. Newsies is a high-energy, non-stop creation that never hits a lull. Am I gushing? Yes, and it’s well deserved.

Newsies stars Daniel Scott Walton as Jack Kelly – a triple-threat who brings swagger, charisma, and heart to the role of the leader of the newsboys. His chemistry with co-star Mary Beth Donahoe as Katherine Plumber is palpable (and they looked like the thoroughly enjoyed every one of their many liplocks!). Donahoe’s sharp-tongued, smart and sassy Katherine flexed all the brawn necessary for a girl to be seen, heard, and taken seriously during an era that did not embrace females in the publishing industry. Jack’s best friend Crutchie, played by Patrick Tombs is the sweetly optimistic and hardily resilient newsie who doesn’t allow his disability to define him (except perhaps where it gains sympathy to sell more papes). Tombs is a terrific talent, who brings to light the importance of casting actors with disabilities.

Alec Cohen as Davey and Benjamin Wohl as Les are a fabulous duo as the brothers who enter the newsies’ world for different reasons. Despite having a family, they’re compelled to bring financial aid their struggling parents – and they offer considerable support to the newsies in helping organize the strike and establish a union. Stuart Marland as Pulitzer is great as the arrogant, unsympathetic man you love to hate; Galyana Castillo is a superb Medda Larkin (and also a Nun), good friend to Jack and the larger-than-life saloon singer who offers her theatre to the newsies.

best_crop_35c0b3c9576b0dc47e17_71642Kudos to the entire rest of the rather large and uber-talented cast who are listed in order of appearance: EJ Dohring as Race and a Citizen of New York; Chris Cardelia as Albert, a Scab, and a Citizen of New York; David Gringrod as Specs and Dance Captain; Kyle Laing as Finch; TJ Kubler as Elmer, Morris Delancy, and a Citizen of New York; Daxx Jayroe Wieser as Romeo, Bill, and a Citizen of New York; Josh Zacher as Tommy Boy, a Scab, and a Citizen of New York; Aliah James as Jo-Jo and a Citizen of New York; Stephanie Eve Parker as Buttons, Spot Conlon, and a Citizen of New York; Bruce Crilly as a Nun, Nunzio, Governor Roosevelt, and a Citizen of New York; Holly Moss as a Nun, Hannah, and a Citizen of New York; Zeke Edmonds as Oscar Delancy and a Citizen of New York; Michael Gorman as Wiesel, Mr. Jacobi, the Mayor, and a Citizen of New York; Gary Lynch as Seitz, Snyder, and a Citizen of New York; and Bill Bateman as Bunsen, Stage Manager, and a Citizen of New York. Shout-outs must also go to Stephen C. Kallas and Tyler Sparacio as Non-Performing Swings.

Additionally, this show couldn’t have been complete without the talent and creativity of the following: set design by Steve Loftus; costume design by Keith Nielsen; lighting design by Andrew Gmoser; sound design by Mark Zuckerman; wig/hair design by Gerard Kelly; properties by Grumpy’s Props; Victor Lukas as Production Stage Manager; Theresa Stark as Assistant Stage Manager; and Colleen Till as Rehearsal Assistant Stage Manager.

As always, WBT provides a great night of dining (if desired) and a show – but this one ranks up there with the best of them. Whether or not you’ve seen Newsies elsewhere, take my word for it, you won’t want to miss it!


He Said:


This pretty much sums up the rave review I am about to give Newsies at Westchester Broadway Theatre (WBT). There was not a weak link in the entire production. The direction, casting, singing, acting, and choreography are all show-stopping in their own way.

Of course, it did not hurt that Newsies is a fabulous show when done properly, based on the Disney film written by Bob Tzudiker and Noni White with music by Alan Menken, lyrics by Jack Feldman, and a fantastic book by none other than Harvey Fierstein.

The story follows the group of rag-tag “newsies” who sell papers for the wealthy publishers like Pulitzer. (Since our novel Going All In written by me and my co-reviewer/wife Stephanie C. Lyons-Keeley did not win a Pulitzer, I feel justified in taking a few pot shots at the character who, for the most part, is played with just the right amount of greed and dark triad narcissism by Stuart Marland.) But I digress. Back to the plot.

castnewsies-2080x1664 (1)Daniel Scott Walton is Mastercard priceless as Jack Kelly, the leader of the newsies who eventually becomes a union organizer. He has the whole package which he displays throughout the play: acting, singing, and dancing. He and his love interest and fellow lead, Mary Beth Donahoe (Katherine Plumber) have great chemistry – so much so that their kisses actually had me squirming a bit in my seat! A special shout must also go to Patrick Tombs whose heart-rendering portrayal of a disabled teen on crutches underscored the emotional drama and historical context of the play.

I would be remiss not to mention the other notables in this highly talented cast. Specifically, Galyana Castillo (Medda Larkin); Alec Cohen (Davey); Benjamin Wohl (Les); Bruce Crilly (who was spot-on as Roosevelt); and Daxx Jayroe Wieser (Romeo). Although I rarely mention the Ensemble other than collectively due to spatial reasons – space be damned. This Ensemble was incredible and included Bill Bateman, Chris Cardelia, EJ Dohring, Zeke Edmonds, Michael Gorman, David Grindrod, Aliah James, TJ Kubler, Kyle Laing, Gary Lynch, Holly Moss, Stephanie Eve Parker, and Josh Zacher.

Kudos also must go to the engaging musical direction of Bob Bray and, of course, the masterful direction of Mark Martino whose vision was palpable. Perhaps it was the set design by Steve Loftus and the brilliant choreography by Shea Sullivan, but every inch of the stage was used to good measure and I must add sitting in the second row was better than any 3-D rendition at an IMAX theatre.

In sum, two words about Newsies – SEE IT!


Read Pillow Talking’s Other Theatre Reviews

Stephanie & Wayne

About Stephanie & Wayne

Stephanie is a journalist, writer, editor, and has had several hundred articles published in various newspapers and magazines, many of which still are available online under “Stephanie Lyons Schultz”. She has a Masters degree in Counseling Psychology and was a practicing psychotherapist. She currently is a professor of psychology at WCSU and NVCC in Connecticut. Wayne is an Emmy-Award winning writer, producer, and director. He has produced many programs and documentaries that have appeared on television, and have been distributed to schools, libraries, and home video. Wayne also is a practicing attorney with a Masters degree in Law from NYU. In addition, he is a professor of communications at WCSU. Together, this recently wed couple write, produce, and direct as many of their stage, screen, and TV projects as they can with a full house -- their combined brood of seven! Some of their work has been featured this summer and fall off off Broadway; other work currently is under option. They hope to continue to promote more of their projects in the coming months! Feel free to write whatever comments you like! We want your feedback!