Pillow Talking’s Review of A CHRISTMAS CAROL (2016)

Someday Productions LLC and Pillow Talking are pleased to present the following review of A CHRISTMAS CAROL: A GHOST STORY OF CHRISTMAS at Hartford Stage



For information about upcoming shows


As chief cook and bottle washer, which includes editing both Wayne’s and my own reviews and blog posts, I will state unequivocally that Wayne and I did NOT read one another’s reviews prior to writing our own.

She Said:

At what point is something deemed a holiday “tradition”? After two years? Five years? Maybe ten? As a kid, every year come December our family did much of the usual: we decorated the Christmas tree and we put up lights outside the house; we baked Christmas cookies and visited with extended family; my siblings and I wore special holiday pajamas on Christmas Eve and then we sat by the fireplace with my father to hear him read ‘Twas the Night Before Christmas (A Visit from St. Nicholas) right before we went off to bed. And sometimes we even dashed outside and scouted across the sky in search of Rudolph’s red nose and Santa’s jingling sleigh. It was cozy and familiar and fantastic; and it all added to the excitement of the season.

But now I’m an adult who’s established some of my own traditions (and even recycled some of the old). For the past two years, my husband (who also is my co-reviewer) and I have been so very fortunate to have two Christmases as a married couple with seven incredible children between us. And during these two beautiful seasons as well, we have been privileged to see and review Hartford Stage’s A Christmas Carol: A Ghost Story of Christmas – for us, a new and very special tradition has been born.

Settling into our seats in the lush theatre (it’s one of my very favorites, I might add) I was as gleeful as a child on Christmas morning while we waited for the lights to go down. Based upon the classic story by Charles Dickens which was adapted by Michael Wilson (Hartford’s Artistic Director from 1998-2011), and directed this year by Artistic Associate Rachel Alderman, we were certain this was going to be pure enchantment from start to finish – and it was! We also were well aware of the great import of this season’s celebrated run – it is the seventeenth and final year for the inimitable Bill Raymond to take the stage as Ebenezer Scrooge.

acc2It is clear that as his swan song, Raymond was determined to pull out all the stops in delivering the most memorable performance possible – and for that I’m equally as thrilled that we also were able to gift my parents with a pair of hard-to-score tickets as one of their Christmas gifts. With impish delight, emitting from Raymond’s lips (both loudly and under his breath) were a bounty of grumbles, cackles, chuckles, and rambles – he’s the crotchety old miser you love to hate and hate to love – and only Raymond can do it with such panache and finesse (and quite a bit of humor), while incorporating some lightsaber combat moves that hardly seem out of place in beautifully staged Victorian England. As shiny as the gold coins he hoards, Raymond is my personal gold standard for the pajama-clad, night cap-wearing geezer.

Staying true to its title, Hartford’s A Christmas Carol is indeed ghost story; however, despite its plethora of phantoms and phantasms, the production is family-friendly. The apparitions come from above, below, and all sides, wreaking havoc on the perfectly miserable life of the man who gives nothing and takes everything. That is until his ghostly visits transform him into the kinder man who was buried beneath his own personal heartache and loss.

acc5The breathtaking sets and moveable set pieces (design by Tony Straiges), spectacular costumes (Alejo Vietti and Zack Brown), and magical props are outstanding enhancements to the top-notch, stellar acting by the entire company. Accented by spot-on lighting design (Robert Wierzel), music and sound design (John Gromada), musical direction (Ken Clark), as well as exceptional choreography (Hope Clarke), this ginormous holiday confection is nothing if not giddily irresistible.

In addition to veteran Raymond, Noble Shropshire reprises his role as Scrooge’s doting housekeeper, Mrs. Dilber, and as the chain-dangling, barking Jacob Marley. How he can keep a straight face is beyond me, but for sure, I could not with his sidesplitting delivery and hysterical facial expressions. Other sterling portrayals are by Johanna Morrison as Spirit of Christmas Past (who also plays Bettye Pidgeon and Old Josie); Alan Rust as Spirit of Christmas Present (who also plays Bert); and Spirit of Christmas Future as “himself.”

acc6With a performance of this caliber, I would be remiss not to include each participant. Each add their own tremendous contribution to the very wonderful totality: Michael Preston as Mr. Marvel; Robert Hannon Davis as Bob Cratchit; Terrell Donnell Sledge as Fred and Scrooge at 30; Flor De Liz Perez as Fred’s Wife and Belle; Rebecka Jones as Mrs. Cratchit and Mrs. Fezziwig; Charlie Tirrell as Mr. Fezziwig, Undertaker, and First Solicitor; Nate Healey as Lamplighter, Scrooge at 14, and Mr. Topper; Buzz Roddy as Second Solicitor; Daniel Shea as Mr. Toby; Hannah Dalessio as Rich Lady; Joey Heimbach as Fiddler; Margaret Anne Murphy as Martha Cratchit. The Ghostly Apparitions and Citizens of London: Vanessa R. Butler (Dance Captain as well as Wendy and Fred’s sister-in-law), Cara Rashkin (also Nichola and Fred’s party guest), Jillian Frankel (also Fred’s party guest), Madeleine Stevens, Spencer S. Lawson (also Fezziwig’s and Fred’s party guests), Troyer Coultas (also Fred’s party guest), and Billy Saunders, Jr. (also Dick Wilkins). It goes without saying that the young actors also bring a flurry of excitement to the stage; they include: Charlize Calcagno or Hunter Cruz who alternate as Tiny Tim, Emma Kindl or Julia Weston as Spoiled Child and Fred’s Party guest; Luciana Calcagno, Nicholas Glowacki, Brendan Reilley Harris, Timothy McGuire, Addison Pancoast or Tilden Wilder as Schoolboys; Miguel Cardona Jr. and Ankit Roy as Boy Scrooge/Fred’s Party guest; Ella Rain Bernaducci or Sophia Rose Tomko as Fan; Celine Cardona or Ava Lynn Vercellone as Belinda Cratchit; Atticus Burrello or Jack Wenz as Peter Cratchit; Fred Faulkner or Max McGowan as Ignorance, Cider Child; Norah Girard or Andrew Michaels as Want, Fruit Child; Ethan Pancoast or Fred Thornley IV as Turkey Boy; and Aidan McMIllan and Dermot McMillan as Ensemble. Greg Seage and Eve Rosenthal are swing.

I personally am sad to see Mr. Raymond retire his night cap, but what an incredible run he’s had! Wishing him well in all of his future endeavors, I do look forward to seeing what magic Hartford Stage and Artistic Director Darko Tresnjak have in store for next year’s show because for certain, we’ll be back (and hopefully with our brood, too)!


He Said:

Tradition: the transmission of customs or beliefs from generation to generation, or the fact of being passed on in this way.

How does a tradition start? It starts from one event which is repeated over and over and eventually gets passed down like the proverbial baton to future generations. Watching Dickens’ A Christmas Carol was a tradition in my household every holiday season and included command performances by every member of the family. We’d sit around the curved television screen on a designated night (no recording back then) and watch Alastair Sim in the 1951 version titled Scrooge (which I still consider the best cinematic interpretation to this day).

We have a new tradition in my family which just started a year ago, but it’s one my wife and I have implanted and intend to involve all of our children at some point. Of course, I am talking about seeing Hartford Stage’s version of Dickens classic: A Christmas Carol: A Ghost Story of Christmas.

Although we are only in our sophomore year of seeing A Christmas Carol at Hartford, it was like returning to a familiar holiday event; one that was anxiously anticipated and ultimately satisfying. The performance directed by Rachel Alderman was flawless. Even having seen it before and knowing what was coming next did not detract from the spontaneity of the live performance. The acting, choreography, staging, lighting, and special effects were brilliantly integrated into this wonderful adaptation of the classic by Michael Wilson.

Hartford Stage, to its credit, has been providing this engaging holiday show for the past nineteen years. Many of the actors and crew people are loyal alumni of past shows. Indeed, the star of the show, veteran actor Bill Raymond, has been donning the Ebenezer Scrooge persona for the past seventeen years and it was an incredible honor to see him perform the role for the last time. His shoes certainly will be difficult to fill. For me, Bill Raymond is to the theatrical Scrooge what Alastair Sim is to the cinematic Scrooge.

acc3The wonderfully versatile Noble Shropshire absolutely killed it as both Mrs. Dilber, Scrooge’s housekeeper and Jacob Marley. Special shout-outs also must go to Alan Rust (Bert/Spirit of Christmas Present), Johanna Morrison (Bettye Pidgeon/Spirit of Christmas Past), Michael Preston (Mr. Marvel), Robert Hannon Davis (Bob Cratchit), and Terrell Donnell Sledge (Fred, Scrooge’s nephew/Scrooge at 30). This insanely talented cast is too large to mention each by name and my bad for seeming to give them short shrift, but they all are integral to bringing this production to life. The same holds true for all of the people behind the scenes, including Hope Clarke (Choregrapher), Tony Straiges (Scenic Design), Alejo Vietti (Costume Design), and Robert Wierzel (Lighting Design).

A Christmas Carol is timeless. It struck a chord with people in Dickens’ time and still does with the populace at large to this day. Why is A Christmas Carol so popular? I think Mr. Raymond sums it up in his parting farewell salute to his tenure as Scrooge:

“A Christmas Carol has an everlasting freshness that fills the heart with hope and caring. It keeps me fresh, It always will…”


Stephanie & Wayne

About Stephanie & Wayne

Stephanie is a journalist, writer, editor, and has had several hundred articles published in various newspapers and magazines, many of which still are available online under “Stephanie Lyons Schultz”. She has a Masters degree in Counseling Psychology and was a practicing psychotherapist. She currently is a professor of psychology at WCSU and NVCC in Connecticut. Wayne is an Emmy-Award winning writer, producer, and director. He has produced many programs and documentaries that have appeared on television, and have been distributed to schools, libraries, and home video. Wayne also is a practicing attorney with a Masters degree in Law from NYU. In addition, he is a professor of communications at WCSU. Together, this recently wed couple write, produce, and direct as many of their stage, screen, and TV projects as they can with a full house -- their combined brood of seven! Some of their work has been featured this summer and fall off off Broadway; other work currently is under option. They hope to continue to promote more of their projects in the coming months! Feel free to write whatever comments you like! We want your feedback!